The End of the American Dream? Why Homeownership Feels Out of Reach for Millennials and Gen Z
From TV, to magazines, to pop culture, the American Dream was one that people all over the world used to share. The promise of homeownership, a representation of security, achievement, and upward mobility, has long been at the heart of the the American Dream. However, that goal is becoming increasingly unattainable for Gen Z and Millennials. Due to an extraordinary crisis brought on by skyrocketing housing costs, stagnating earnings, and structural obstacles, millions of people are beginning to doubt if homeownership is even possible or even worthwhile.
The data presents a dismal image. The average home in the 1980s cost around three times the median yearly salary. In many regions of the nation, that number has now skyrocketed to more than seven times. The median price of a property in the United States in 2023 was $416,100, which most young folks could not have imagined, according to the National Association of Realtors.
Financial setbacks such as student loan debt and stagnating salaries have made saving for a down payment all but impossible for Millennials, who grew up during the Great Recession. Gen Z faces an even more formidable obstacle when they enter the workforce at a time of record inflation and rising interest rates.
In cities like Austin, New York, and San Francisco, the housing market has turned into a competitive frenzy as cash offers and bidding wars have driven up prices beyond what the majority of young purchasers can afford. However, rising mortgage rates—which are currently above 7% for the first time in 20 years—have turned the goal of homeownership into a financial nightmare, even in less expensive areas.
Source: Shutterstock
The difficulties extend beyond the state of the market. Inequality in the housing market has been firmly established by a number of systemic obstacles. To begin with, racial inequities still exist. Millennials of color, particularly Black and Hispanic, are less likely to receive generational wealth transfers that could finance a down payment and have higher rejection rates for mortgage applications.
Furthermore, younger generations are disproportionately affected by the weight of student loan debt, which is a millstone around the neck of around 45 million Americans. It’s understandable that many Millennials and Gen Zers believe homeownership is unattainable given the average debt of $37,000 per borrower.
Private equity groups and corporate investors have also pounced on the housing market as a profitable investment opportunity, purchasing single-family homes to turn into rental apartments. In addition to driving up property values, this trend reduces the number of available properties for potential purchasers. For more and more young people, the question is not only if they can afford a home, but also if they should. The idea that becoming a homeowner is the ultimate mark of achievement is being rejected by Millennials and Gen Z more and more.
Values around housing are changing due to the flexibility of renting, the desire to value experiences over material belongings, and the effects of expansive suburban developments on the environment. With so much mobility and opportunity available in the world, why commit to a 30-year mortgage in an uncertain economy?
However, this change in culture isn’t totally voluntary. Many young individuals are dismissing the goal entirely in an attempt to justify their incapacity to purchase a property. In actuality, renting frequently lacks the long-term financial security and wealth-building opportunities associated with buying, although providing freedom.
Systemic change is necessary if the dream of homeownership is to be revived. In order to solve affordability, Americans must first implement targeted housing policies. A few policies that could help level the playing field include expanding the construction of affordable housing units, restricting the amount of properties investors can buy in a particular market, and extending access to first-time buyer programs. Second, student loan debt needs to be taken seriously by the government. Restructuring or canceling debt would provide young buyers with substantial financial resources and bring much-needed liquidity to the real estate market.
Lastly, there is a role for the private sector. In order to meet the needs of today’s workforce, including gig economy workers who might not have standard income documents but are nonetheless creditworthy, financial institutions should update their lending procedures.
The American Dream has always changed over time to take into account the conditions of the day. It could be time to reinterpret it for Millennials and Gen Z as a 21st-century vision of stability and opportunity rather than as a rigid ideal based on white picket fences.
Still, the systemic barriers to homeownership cannot be ignored. Addressing these challenges isn’t just about preserving a cultural ideal—it’s about ensuring that the wealth gap doesn’t widen further and that young people can build secure, meaningful lives. If Americans fail to act, the dream of homeownership may indeed become a relic of the past—a museum exhibit of what was once possible in America. And that loss would be a tragedy, not just for Millennials and Gen Z, but for the nation as a whole.
By Ioana Constantin
